Skip to content
A hand holds a black truffle still covered in soil
A black truffle still covered in soil, held in a hand. House photograph.

Buying and choosing

Assessing a truffle batch on arrival: checks and a kitchen trial

Before preparation, compare the pieces with the order and documents. Record condition, weight and discrepancies, then test a stable preparation: batch conformity and suitability for your recipe are separate questions.

Written by the La Truffe française teamUpdated on

How do you compare two batches of black truffles?

Ask for the scientific name, declared origin and traceability details for each batch. Match the stated maturity, condition of the pieces, net weight and size to your intended use. Size does not establish maturity, and the name ‘truffe du Périgord’ does not prove a Périgord harvest. Then compare the total price for the same weight and tax basis, including transport and other stated charges.

La Truffe française

Published on

Updated

Your business guide : Truffles in a restaurant: from choosing the product to the first service

Before the batch enters mise en place

Have the truffles received by someone who knows the order. First compare stated species, net weight and format with the delivered pieces, then examine their condition and transport arrangements. Checking is easier while the batch remains identifiable. Once several deliveries share one container, explaining a discrepancy to a supplier becomes much harder.

An irregular piece may suit a chopped preparation while failing a request for large slices. Record the difference from the agreed format rather than calling the whole batch ‘good’ or ‘bad’. If its condition raises a food-safety concern, suspend use under the establishment’s procedures: tasting is not a way to clear that concern.

What an examination can record

Article 3 of the French 2012 decree sets quality criteria for fresh truffles sold to final consumers. These do not by themselves define your professional contract: compare your observations with the characteristics agreed with the supplier.

In the record, separate your observations from the supplier’s declarations. A dark cut surface alone does not certify species or origin.

  1. Firmness: compare the pieces and record differences in consistency; size alone does not establish maturity.
  2. Aroma: smell pieces separately and record any foreign odour instead of relying on the container’s scent.
  3. Condition: record visible damage, parasites or traces, and unusual surface moisture. Suspend use if food safety is in doubt.
  4. Cut: if a small inspection cut is agreed, examine the fresh cut with the supplier to discuss maturity. It does not certify the species on its own.
  5. Documents: match the scientific name, declared origin and weight to the delivered pieces. Aroma and photographs do not replace these details.

A short record that stays with the product

Keep one record per batch linked to the delivery note: received and usable weight, presentation, condition, instructions and decision. For a kitchen trial, record the preparation, added weight, addition point and time to tasting. The fields below are for your team to complete; they do not describe trials performed by the House.

Connect the record to the delivery note and invoice. If a detail is missing, write ‘not supplied’ and request it; do not infer origin from where you met the seller. Where the scientific name is missing, Article 5 specifies where naming information must accompany fresh truffles, including stages before sale to the final consumer.

  1. Receipt: supplier, order reference, date, time and responsible person.
  2. Identification: batch, common and scientific names, declared origin and supporting document.
  3. Order and product: ordered weight, observed net weight, agreed format and observations about the pieces.
  4. Use: storage instructions, planned service and kitchen trial result if performed.
  5. Decision: acceptance, clarification requested or use suspended; supplier response and follow-up.

Accept, request clarification or suspend use

Separate three situations in your notes. The product matches the order and its use is confirmed. Commercial information or a format discrepancy needs clarification. Or its condition raises a hygiene concern: do not serve it and follow your establishment’s procedures with the designated manager. A sauce must not become a way to conceal a receiving problem.

Promptly send the supplier the reference, observations and relevant photographs, then record the response. The DGCCRF hygiene guidance explains food businesses’ responsibility for product safety and traceability. Assessing aroma informs your culinary choice; it does not replace that hygiene responsibility.

To assess culinary use of an accepted batch, compare the same base without truffle and with the intended weighed portion. Taste at your actual service pace and describe perceptible or masked aroma, texture, slicing and balance with the sauce. Keep the notes with the batch reference. They inform a recipe decision, not food-safety clearance or identity and origin analysis.

Species, origin and size: keep the criteria separate

Start with the scientific name on each offer. Do not compare two batches sold as ‘black truffle’ on price alone when the species is unspecified. The French order of 19 March 2015 associates the common names ‘truffe du Périgord’ and ‘truffe noire du Périgord’ with Tuber melanosporum. Those names do not prove that the batch was harvested in the Périgord or in France: ask separately for its declared origin and batch traceability information.

Size tells you about the size or weight of individual pieces; it does not establish maturity or aroma intensity on its own. A large piece and small pieces serve different slicing needs, but format does not replace examining the batch. Ask how the stated maturity was assessed and, if known, the harvest date. The DGCCRF recommends checking the species’ harvest periods to better assess maturity.

A table to complete when comparing two offers

When comparing two offers, complete this table before ordering and revisit it on arrival. Link each answer to a document or identifiable exchange; keep ‘not provided’ when information is missing. The table organises comparison and questions without turning a seller’s declaration into your own verified finding.

Scroll the table sideways to read every column.

Pre-order comparison template: document two offers
CriterionOffer AOffer BQuestion when information is missing
Stated speciesTo completeTo completeWhat scientific name? Is a substitution proposed?
Batch originTo completeTo completeWhich country, harvest area and documents for this batch?
Stated maturity and conditionTo completeTo completeHow was maturity assessed? Is the harvest date known?
Net weight, size and presentationTo completeTo completeWhat weight excluding packaging? Whole truffles or cut pieces, and what sizes?
Total price for the chosen weightTo completeTo completeSame tax basis? Are packaging, transport and other charges included or separate?
Planned receipt and useTo completeTo completeWhat receipt date and conditions are proposed for your service?

Compare the total for the quantity actually ordered

Use the same net weight, format and tax basis for two quotations. Add batch price, packaging, transport and other stated charges. A fixed delivery charge can change the comparison when quantity changes: request a new total for your exact order instead of extrapolating an old offer.

The total does not replace checking the batch. Also compare species, declared origin, available harvest information, stated maturity and suitability for your recipe. Receipt and service dates must remain compatible with the offered product’s storage instructions.

What to ask the seller next

Keep the answers with the chosen offer, then use the same reference on receipt. For the next steps, the readings on buying for a restaurant and storing fresh truffles complement this table; they do not replace batch-specific information or your establishment’s procedures.

  1. Can you confirm the scientific name, declared origin and batch references, and flag any proposed substitution?
  2. What net weight and piece format are proposed for our use? How was the stated maturity assessed?
  3. What is the total on the stated tax basis, including packaging, transport and any other charges for this exact quantity?
  4. What receipt arrangements and storage guidance accompany the batch? Who should receive a discrepancy recorded on the receiving record?

Prepare your supply enquiry

After receiving and trialling the product, you can request a reorder with your observations to prepare the next batch.

To prepare the next batch, you can return to the supplier brief alongside your receiving notes.

Enquire about fresh truffle supply for your restaurant

Sources and references

Our editorial approach

La Truffe française is responsible for these guides. Information about our offer comes from the House; technical resources cited in each article are identified separately.

Collection or delivery

Collection by appointment. Delivery at your expense, on request.

Find out more

Need advice?

Size, quantity or recipe? Contact us.

Find out more

The art of giving

Signature presentation and a personal message.

Find out more

Price on enquiry

According to the market and the week’s harvest.

Find out more
WhatsApp